Page 1 of 1
[TC 8.5 ß1] Explain exclamation meaning mark in tooltip
Posted: 2013-09-02, 15:30 UTC
by Lefteous
There is a new feature in TC 8.5 which is described as
Code: Select all
26.02.13 Added: Show exclamation mark to the left of some checkboxes to warn user about possible problems: Copy: keep relative dirs from branch view, ZIP: not preserving path, not storing recursively, Unzip: Not unpacking paths, overwriting files without confirmation, FTP upload: Converting to lowercase, Search: In archives (32/64)
I just started a search and there was an exclamation mark near to search in archives. The problem here is that there is no explanation displayed why there is an exclamation mark.
I really think the basic idea of this feature is very good but currently it's not yet self-explanatory.
My suggestion goes here:
Display a simple tooltip when hovering over the exclamation mark explaining why the exclamation mark is displayed.
Posted: 2013-09-02, 18:04 UTC
by MVV
I tried to locate these marks but with no success. Please describe how I can see them... There are no any marks in dialogs. Maybe I need some special theme?
Posted: 2013-09-02, 21:00 UTC
by sqa_wizard
Support, a tooltip will be helpful
Please describe how I can see them...
It is a little bit tricky
You can see them only if an option is still enabled by a previous run.
e.g.
1. run a search with "Search in archives" option enabled (no mark yet)
2. close search dialog
3. reopen search dialog (now mark is shown)
Posted: 2013-09-03, 09:52 UTC
by MVV
Wow, thank you, sqa_wizard, I see it!
BTW I think red color would be more noticeable...
Posted: 2013-09-03, 13:47 UTC
by Sir_SiLvA
But is some kind of standard to use yellow and red would look fucking hell ugly
Posted: 2013-09-03, 14:41 UTC
by ghisler(Author)
Red is more for errors, yellow is for warnings. It should just warn the user that an unusual option was set in a previous operation.
Posted: 2013-10-21, 16:54 UTC
by Lefteous
2ghisler(Author)
I still think a tooltip which explains the exclamation mark would be very helpful. Would do you think?
Posted: 2013-10-21, 17:06 UTC
by Bluestar
Lefteous wrote:2ghisler(Author)
I still think a tooltip which explains the exclamation mark would be very helpful.
+1. I also seen an exclamation mark in a dialog while doing usual tasks in TC, but had no clue at all what could that mean.
By the way its color is totally fine IMO; red is for errors, it shouldn't be changed - fine as is.
Posted: 2013-10-28, 09:02 UTC
by Lefteous
After working for many weeks with this new feature I have to say it doesn't work so well for me in certain cases. This case is when I already the decision to just confirm a dialog (for example in unpack files). I think the problem is that the exclmation mark is not enough to hold me back to continue into the unwanted operation (unpack without paths in the example above).
I think we need something visually more eye-catching like another background color.
Another way could be to actually warn the user in a modal dialog in the case that the dialog was opened with the 'special option'.